Nursing
shortage threatens your health care
Aging population swells demand, but
long hours and stressful, risky work
steer many into other fields
By
JENNIFER GOLDBLATT
Staff reporter
06/20/2004
Debbie Crowell spent two decades in
the food sales and brokerage
business. But at age 40, her
yearning to take care of others took
over. She went back to school and
became a registered nurse.
"It was something that was like a
burning desire," said Crowell, a
Georgetown resident who works at
Beebe Medical Center's Tunnell
Cancer Center in Lewes. "I wanted to
give something back."
Sure, the work is tough. Like all
nurses, she has to deal with the
pressures of having someone else's
life in her hands.
"But it's just this gratification
you get from patients," she said. "I
love my job. It's not easy and we
work hard, but you feel good coming
home. And you feel good coming to
work. A lot of people don't have
that luxury."
Delaware would like to find more
people like Crowell. The state needs
about 800 more registered nurses
than it has, and that shortage is
expected to grow more critical. By
next year, Delaware could be short
by more than 2,126 nurses, or 29
percent, according to a study by the
federal Health Resources and
Services Administration. In 2020,
Delaware will have only half the
number of nurses that it needs.
"It's not going away anytime
soon," said Joe Letnaunchyn,
president of the Delaware Healthcare
Association. "There's still a
challenge of being able to meet the
need and provide the ongoing
educational opportunities for people
interested in nursing and the allied
health professions."
Statewide, one in 10 nursing jobs
is vacant. The shortage is most
critical at the five state-owned,
long-term care facilities, where
nearly a third of nursing jobs are
vacant.
Experts attribute the shortage to
a variety of factors:
• The aging population is
causing the demand for nurses to
swell.
• Advances in health care
treatments that did not exist years
ago are creating more demand for
nursing staff.
• Women who traditionally
flocked to the nursing field have
more professional opportunities
today.
• Nurses have more
opportunities to work in
non-hospital settings, such as
offices and outpatient surgery
centers, which do not require staff
24 hours a day.
• Pay in nursing has been
relatively flat for some time.
• It's a difficult job.
"The nurses in the profession
think it's the best job in the
world. But it can be physically
difficult, very stressful and
emotionally draining," said Carol
Cooke, a spokeswoman for the
American Nurses Association. "Couple
that with a work environment that
doesn't pay what it should, and it
can be a pretty dire picture."
Nurses account for about half of
all health care workers, and studies
show that they play a key role in
monitoring patients' health status.
Inadequate numbers of nurses are
associated with increased
infections, bleeding and cardiac and
respiratory failure, studies show.
About 53 percent of physicians and
65 percent of the public cited the
nursing shortage as a leading cause
of medical errors, according to a
2002 survey published in the New
England Journal of Medicine.
The crisis is worsening
nationally and locally because of
the graying of health care workers
and consumers. There has been
explosive growth in Delaware's
retiree population, particularly in
Sussex County. The nurses, too, are
getting older, and there is concern
that as they retire, there won't be
enough young nurses to replace them.
The average age of a nurse is 45
nationwide and 43 in Delaware. Only
9 percent of nurses nationally are
younger than 30.
"A lot of nurses are going to be
going into retirement age," said
Nancy Rubino, president of the
Delaware Nurses Association. "If we
don't replace them, our shortage is
going to be dramatic."
Working long hours
The shortage has meant that more
nurses are asked to work overtime,
and more health facilities hire
nurses from temporary agencies to
fill the gaps. But those solutions
have created new challenges.
More than two-thirds of nurses
work overtime each month, according
to a survey by the American Nurses
Association. While some nurses
welcome overtime, burnout is a risk.
"Any nurse that wants overtime
can get it. But we're all trying to
be judicious as to how much overtime
to give," said Yrene Waldron,
executive director of the Delaware
Health Care Facilities Association.
"If a nurse works three 15-hour
shifts in a row, by the third day,
she is burned out and tired. And is
her judgment going to be good?"
Hiring nurses from temporary
agencies avoids overtime but carries
a high cost. The average hourly wage
for an agency registered nurse in
Delaware was $49.81, compared with
$29.44 for a staff registered nurse,
according to a survey of the state's
nursing wage rates.
Temporary nurses get expensive
for long-term care facilities such
as the state-owned Emily P. Bissell
Hospital, which has a 67 percent
vacancy rate for nurses. Hospital
officials say that, while they use
temporary nurses for some jobs, they
cannot provide all the services of a
staff nurse.
"We really need to have our own
staff for the continuity of care and
for documentation purposes, to do
comprehensive assessments on the
residents," said Janet Parr,
director of nursing at Bissell.
"Unless they're here all the time,
they can't do that."
Three-year-old state nursing home
reforms require long-term care
facilities to provide a minimum of
3.28 hours of nursing care to each
patient each day. Meant to ensure
that there were no gaps in care,
those rules and the nursing shortage
have forced the long-term care
facilities to reduce the number of
beds they have. The state had to
reduce the number of patients in its
five facilities from 440 to 378.
"It's not a situation we want to
be in, but we don't have a choice,"
said Vince Meconi, secretary of the
Delaware Department of Health and
Social Services. "You can't be in a
situation where you have staff not
providing the standard of care and
you're putting patients at risk."
State gets involved
Last year, the state made an
effort to help find a long-term
solution: train more nurses.
Gov. Ruth Ann Minner announced a
$1.8 million program to pay for new
faculty positions at Delaware
Technical & Community College.
The state also provided $125,000
in scholarships to 52 students to
attend nursing programs at Beebe
Nursing School, the University of
Delaware, Delaware State University,
Wilmington College and Wesley
College. In exchange for the
scholarships, students had to commit
to work at local hospitals,
long-term facilities or one of the
Department of Health and Social
Services facilities after
graduation.
In addition, the state provided
$204,171 through its Department of
Health and Social Services, Health
Care Association and Health
Facilities Association to 63
students at Delaware Technical &
Community College.
Some schools are clamoring for
more. Last year, Beebe accepted 62
students. But half of them were put
on a waiting list because of limited
space. Beebe is trying to get
federal funds to finance a $3.4
million expansion for its school of
nursing to add classes and lab
space.
Expanding the capacity of the
83-year-old nursing school is
particularly crucial because a
significant portion of the students
stay to work at Beebe after they
graduate. About 20 of the 26
students stayed at Beebe last year
to work.
Work incentives
Hospitals have taken action on
their own, trying to woo nurses with
signing bonuses, free education and
by selling the profession as fun.
Beebe has run ads featuring
nurses clad in scrubs and sunglasses
with beach balls in hand. The
hospital has also tried to bring
levity to the work environment, with
plenty of office parties, picnics,
Hawaiian shirt days and even by
bringing in a professional humorist
for National Nurses Week.
"Health care is very stressful,
and we want our employees to feel
some lightness in this stressful
environment they walk into," said
Bonnie Burke, a human resources
specialist with Beebe, where 3
percent of nursing positions are
vacant.
At Bayhealth Medical Center, 2.9
percent of nursing positions are
vacant, down from 9 percent a year
ago, according to Judy Martin,
senior vice president for patient
care services. She attributes that,
in large part, to a hospital-wide
re-evaluation of the hiring and
retention process. The hospital has
created a mentoring program, a
six-month fellowship and an
environment more conducive to
professional advancement.
At Alfred I. duPont Hospital for
Children in Rockland, the vacancy
rate is 7.5 percent. The hospital
has established a summer extern
program for nursing students who
have completed a clinical rotation,
and an internship for the pediatric
intensive care unit. It also offers
loan forgiveness and tuition
reimbursement.
At Christiana Care, about 5
percent of nursing jobs are
typically unfilled. Recruitment has
benefited from its recent ranking
among the top 5 percent of all
hospitals for clinical excellence by
HealthGrades, a national health care
quality ranking firm, said Joan G.
Thomas, senior vice president for
facilities and services at the
hospital.
The hospital is working to get
certification through the American
Nurses Association's nursing
excellence program. The program
requires the hospital to meet
certain standards established by the
national trade group. Those
standards include involving
employees in key decision-making
roles and having an atmosphere that
is conducive to their career
advancement.
One of the keys to retaining
nurses in the long term has been
getting them the resources they need
to meet the physical demands of the
job, Rubino said. Fewer than 20
percent of nurses feel safe in their
current work environment, according
to the American Nurses Association.
And the top concerns at work are a
disabling back injury or contracting
HIV or hepatitis.
Given the aging work force,
getting the proper and
state-of-the-art equipment is
particularly important.
"Just making those simple things
available would make a big
difference," Rubino said. "Once we
get them in there, we have to make
sure that the environment that
they're working in is one that keeps
them there. Right now there are a
lot of other employment
opportunities that can attract
people away from our profession."
At St. Francis Hospital, about 8
percent of nursing jobs are vacant.
For the past 18 months, a group of
senior hospital leaders has been
evaluating salaries, benefits,
sign-on bonuses and opportunities to
give nurses more autonomy in their
work and more education. One
challenge is recruiting the kind of
people who are going to be in the
profession for the long haul.
"You have to be cut out to do
it," said Pat Winston, chief nursing
officer. "Some people think that if
they get into it, the money is good
and that they'll always have a job.
But the work is hard. And if the
money is the only reason you come
in, you don't last, and everybody
has wasted their time." |